Angela Jack

Experience

• Optis v Apple: Part of the UK team acting for the Optis group in patent dispute with Apple including working on trials which found that no estoppel defence arose out “late” declarations of standard essential patents (Trial B) and in a trial which found that Apple were not at that time entitled to enforce the ETSI undertaking against Optis and that Apple would accordingly be injuncted unless Apple committed to enter into a FRAND licence to be determined by the High Court of England and Wales (Trial F). Currently part of the FRAND trial team.
• Lead associate at EIP acting for Unwired Planet in the Court of Appeal, successfully resisting the appeal brought by Huawei in FRAND proceedings. (link)
• Lead associate at EIP in the Unwired Planet v Huawei FRAND proceedings (link)
• Technetix v Teleste. Acting for Teleste in successfully defending them against a claim of patent infringement brought in the IPEC. The case was widely reported, as it was the first time that the English courts had considered the existence of a “Formstein defence”. The court held that the asserted patent was invalid and also held that whilst the alleged infringement would have fallen within the scope of the claims under the doctrine of equivalents, Teleste would have been entitled to a Formstein defence, if such a defence exists in English law. (link)
• Urgent anti-suit proceedings to ensure the discontinuance of proceedings commenced in China by Huawei which sought to relitigate matters already determined in Unwired Planet v Huawei [2017] EWHC 711 (Pat) and to recover monies payable in accordance with that decision
• Unwired Planet International Limited v Huawei, Samsung and Google. Acting as part of the team for Unwired Planet in its enforcement of EP (UK) 0,989,712
• Good Technology v MobileIron. Acting as part of the team for Good Technology Inc in patent litigation in the field of mobile device management (link)

Recent work

• Acting for Unwired Planet and Conversant Wireless in successful Supreme Court proceedings against Huawei (and ZTE for Conversant) on the issue of FRAND in the context of Standard Essential Patents (SEPs) in the field of telecommunication. (link)
• Acting for Teleste in successfully defending a claim for patent infringement by Technetix BV in the United Kingdom Patents Court in the field of cable TV equipment. (link)
• Acting for Unwired Planet and Conversant in the Supreme Court appeals brought by Huawei and ZTE. (link)
• Acting for Conversant in the FRAND aspects of Conversant v Huawei and ZTE.
• High Court patent litigation in the field of CATV electronics.

Published articles

• March 2024
  Solicitors Journal, Court of Appeal dismisses Tesco’s appeal in trade mark dispute with Lidl (link)
• May 2023
  Solicitors Journal, A closer look at the trademark dispute between retail giants Lidl and Tesco (link)
• March 2023
  EIP News Flashes, A pig in wolf’s clothing? Wolfoo unable to avoid valid service by providing multiple email addresses for service. (link)
• December 2022
  EIP News Flashes, Kigen v Thales: Can an implementer bring a stand-alone claim for FRAND determination? (link)
• November 2022
  EIP News Flashes, Supermarkets trademark battle to consider bad faith allegations (link)
• September 2021
  Law 360, Takeaways On Pre-Action Protocols From UK Patent Ruling (link)
• September 2016
  JIPLP, More pain for Pfizer-second medical use claims not infringed (link)